So, once again I’m writing a eulogy for a band. I really hate doing these, but sometimes it is necessary to mark the passing of a really good band. On January 2nd Hopesfall announced that the rumors that Hopesfall had broken up were completely and entirely true. The breakup marks the end of Hopesfall just before the decade mark and ends rumors that the line-up that had been touring in support of the 2007 release Magnetic North would be rechristening the band.
The breakup marks the end of a very rocky yet successful nine-plus years of existence for Hopesfall. The band was probably best known and loved for their 2002 album The Satellite Years, which, along with Thursday’s Full Collapse, marked the end of the post-hardcore era and the beginning of the emo era *writer shudders* and the re-emergence of hardcore. The 2002 release on Trustkill Records was followed by the 2004 Trustkill release A Types.
On A Types the band (which was, at the time of recording, only 1/3 of the band that recorded The Satellite Years) moved away from the heavy post-hardcore style of TSY and toward a more melodic, darker sound. A Types did not receive the media attention of TSY, but when reviewed alone, it has stood up as a quality album.
Hopesfall’s final release was Magnetic North, for which only the lead singer, Jay Forrest, remained from the TSY days. Released in mid-2007, Magnetic North was hailed as a perfect blend of TSY and A Types. The good reviews were overshadowed by the news that the new line-up brought together for the recording and touring of Magnetic North was already disengaging at the time of the release. On January 2, drummer Jason Trabue posted a note on Myspace (it used to be that bands controlled their websites…but that’s a rant for next time) that the band was no longer in existence and that Jason “hated Trustkill Records and its owner.” He also said that while the Trustkill situation was not the only reason for the break-up, it was a part of it.
While I am not going to make any comments about the circumstances of the break-up, I will say that underground music is losing a band that, despite their frequent line-up changes, has been a model of how a band should function.
Good luck to all the former members of Hopesfall.